The song "Damnation's Cellar" by Elvis Costello & The Brodsky Quartet explores the idea of a time machine that can bring back famous historical figures and how that would impact society. The lyrics begin with a mention of marmalade and eggs, indicating a casual and mundane setting. The narrator then mentions the construction of a time machine, hinting at a significant development that could change everything. The song suggests that with the invention of a time machine, there would be no need for obituary pages because people could bring back heroes from the past. The argument about this idea catches fire as people debate its implications and consequences. The chorus contemplates the choice between leaving these figures in their respective time periods or bringing them to the present. The phrase "tallow into tar" could symbolize a transformation from something unremarkable and expendable to something valuable and lasting. The lyrics touch on the idea that science can explain and recreate anything, even deities, which challenges traditional beliefs. It suggests that science can remove the blame or mysticism associated with certain phenomena. The song asks the listener to quickly speak up if there is anyone they would like to see again, suggesting that time travel could be limited or temporary. It then mentions figures like Da Vinci, "La Giaconda" (referring to Leonardo da Vinci's painting, the Mona Lisa), Nijinsky (a famous ballet dancer), and even a horse. The line implies that time travel would be faster and more efficient than studying history or going through personal struggles. The chorus repeats, emphasizing the decision to bring back famous figures and the implications it may have. The song suggests bringing back Liberace (a famous pianist), Laurel and Hardy (comedic duo), Elvis Presley, and Puccini (an Italian composer). It remarks that while society may eagerly bring back these figures, it is hard to believe we are burning through valuable resources and opportunities with such enthusiasm. The lyrics convey a sense of curiosity and questions about justice and solving mysteries, mentioning figures like Hitler and Lee Harvey Oswald. It then transitions to a desire for beauty and pleasure, suggesting that people would prefer someone "blonder" or more physically appealing. However, it concludes that bringing back historical figures may never fully please humanity. In the final lines, the song implies that society is destroying something valuable, possibly referring to the natural world or the promise of progress, and that a decision has been made to continue down this destructive path. Overall, "Damnation's Cellar" reflects on the implications and dilemmas of time travel and the human desire to bring back famous figures from history. It touches on themes of nostalgia, societal values, and the consequences of our choices.
