The song "Why Not Us" by Aaron Goodvin is about two people who have experienced past heartbreak and believe they don't deserve to find love again. Despite their hesitation, they feel a strong connection and are drawn to each other. The lyrics suggest that the couple is hesitant to fully commit to a relationship due to the pain and mistakes of their pasts. However, they realize that they can't continue to run away from love and that they both deserve happiness. The line "We both have a heart, can't keep 'em in the dark" emphasizes their desire to embrace their feelings and not hide them anymore. The song also conveys the idea that the challenges they have faced in the past have prepared them to be better partners for each other. They believe that their brokenness has shaped them into a perfect fit, and they can feel the connection strongly in the present moment. The chorus of the song expresses their desire to be in love like everyone else. They question why they can't experience love and happiness like others and why they should let fear hold them back. The repeated line "Why not us" highlights their longing for a chance at love and the hope that they can overcome their fears. Overall, "Why Not Us" is a song about taking a chance on love despite past heartbreak and embracing the possibility of finding happiness and a deep connection with someone new. It encourages the listeners to trust in love and believe that they deserve to find happiness just like anyone else.