The song "Sweet Potato Pie" by Al Jarreau tells the story of a hot, sticky morning around the Fourth of July. The singer is spending time alone and enjoying the company of the voices inside his head. He expresses gratitude to the Lord for bringing lighter times to his mind. The lyrics then shift to a comparison between sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie. The singer emphasizes that once someone has tasted sweet potato pie, they no longer desire pumpkin pie. Addressing a city boy, the singer advises him not to be fooled by imitations and to appreciate the authenticity of sweet potato pie. He encourages the listener to share this delicious dish with someone they love, warning that once they experience it, they won't want pumpkin pie again. The narrative moves to a visit with a friend named Sissy. She asks the singer to choose between a box and a fancy question mark, symbolizing personal identity. The singer reassures Sissy that she doesn't need to worry, using the metaphor of a blind mule and a wagon. He suggests that Sissy should hold on to her values while he figures out his true self. The song then transports the listener to a dream about gates made of gold and pearl, symbolizing heaven. The singer envisions a reunion with an old friend and expresses a desire for comfort through simple pleasures, like milk, honey, and a pot of stew. The chorus is repeated, emphasizing that anyone who has tasted sweet potato pie no longer desires pumpkin pie. The song concludes with a plea for someone to share some sweet potato pie.
