The song "Past My Prime" by Hovey Benjamin is a comedic and self-deprecating exploration of the artist's reflections on wasted opportunities and unfulfilled potential. Through humorous lyrics, Benjamin contemplates on his athletic, sexual, and personal prime, expressing regret for not taking certain paths in life. In the first verse, Benjamin realizes that he has missed his athletic prime, feeling like time has slipped away. He acknowledges that he will never become a professional athlete or make it to the NBA. Instead, he feels he has wasted his time making music and wishes he had focused on pursuing a sports career. Moving on to the second verse, Benjamin reflects on his sexual prime, expressing disappointment in not exploring his potential as a sex symbol. He humorously compares himself to famous adult film star Ron Jeremy and regrets not trying new experiences. He contemplates turning to a life of crime due to his perceived lack of options. The chorus emphasizes Benjamin's sentiment of regret for not fully pursuing his passions and talents. He believes he should have focused on sports or sexual endeavors instead of comedy and music. The humor in his lyrics stems from the exaggeration of his missed opportunities. In the third verse, Benjamin acknowledges that he missed his opportunity to become a famous movie star like Optimus Prime from the Transformers franchise. He playfully fantasizes about having a sentient ride and fighting robots in the sky. However, he realizes that these dreams are not feasible as Transformers and Shia LaBeouf are not real. The song concludes with a twist of irony when Benjamin mentions having Amazon Prime. He humorously mentions this as his only remaining "prime," highlighting the satirical nature of the song, as it transitions from serious regrets to playful absurdities. Overall, "Past My Prime" is a lighthearted and comedic song that satirizes the concept of wasted potential and missed opportunities in various aspects of life. It highlights the artist's self-deprecating humor and plays with exaggerated fantasies and regrets.