The song "Make Me Believe It" by Jack Wagner is about a person who feels like something is missing in their relationship. Their partner assures them that their love is real and strong, but the narrator is afraid that the magic and passion have faded away. The narrator wishes to feel the love and connection they once had, wanting their partner to make them believe in it again. They long for the reassurance and want to know that their partner's love is still true. The narrator questions if they could be wrong and if their imagination is playing tricks on them, hoping that their partner still cares and can find a way to show them that the feeling is still there. Ultimately, the song is about the narrator's desire for their partner to reignite the love and passion in their relationship, to make them believe in it again and to assure them that their love is still true.