The song "One of the Three" by James is open to interpretation and can be seen in different ways depending on the listener. However, based on the lyrics provided, the following is one possible explanation of its meaning and story. The song suggests that the person being referred to was one of three individuals who had a significant impact or presence in some way. It could be a reference to a group of friends or even a larger context, such as society or a movement. The line "One in three must find some peace" could imply that out of these three individuals, only one can find inner peace or resolve their issues. The group or society might be searching for peace, but only one member can achieve it. The lyrics also emphasize the need for proof before belief. This may suggest that the person being referred to had some unconventional ideas or beliefs that required evidence or validation from others. It could be a critique of blind faith or a call for critical thinking. The lines "You just knew they'd come for you, so it was suicide" and "I guess you're not to blame for what they've done in your name" hint at a sense of betrayal. It seems that this individual anticipated some negative consequences or scrutiny, which eventually led to their death by suicide. It's also implied that their fame came as a result of their sacrifice. The phrase "You sent forth your lamb to the slaughter" further reinforces the idea of sacrifice. It suggests that the person being sung about willingly put themselves in harm's way, possibly for a greater cause or belief. Overall, "One of the Three" appears to convey a sense of tragedy, where an individual's actions or ideas lead to their demise. It explores themes of sacrifice, fame, belief, and the need for validation. However, it's important to note that interpretations of songs can vary, and the true meaning may be left open for individual interpretation.
