"What Is It Good For" is a song by James, a British indie rock band. The song explores themes of heartbreak, personal struggle, and the desire for a miracle or redemption. The lyrics suggest that the narrator has made foolish mistakes repeatedly and is now facing the consequences. They feel vulnerable and unable to protect their heart from further pain. The line "I've been a fool again, won't let it show" implies that the narrator is trying to hide their emotions and the mistakes they've made. The mention of 'poison fruit' symbolizes the toxic choices or actions the narrator has taken, which have weakened them. They fear that their partner will leave them for someone else, adding to their pain. The narrator expresses hope that a miracle can save them from their current situation. They plead for a miracle to work, as it could offer a solution or a way out. However, they also acknowledge their uncertainty by questioning what is truly good for them. The song touches upon feelings of brokenness and questions the purpose or value of the hardships they are facing. The repeated lyrics of "Broken, it's all broken, what is it good for?" reflect the narrator's frustration and confusion about the meaning of their struggles. In the end, the narrator acknowledges their lack of understanding about what is truly good for them. They are seeking clarity, guidance, or a transformative event that can help them overcome their pain and find a positive resolution. Overall, "What Is It Good For" is a introspective and emotional song that delves into the turmoil of heartbreak and the search for meaning in difficult experiences. It highlights the human desire for redemption and the need for hope in times of despair.
