The song "Why Baby Why" is actually not by James Taylor, but by George Jones. It was released as a single in 1955 and became one of his early hits. The lyrics of the song depict a person in a troubled relationship, pleading with their partner to explain why they make them cry and hurt them. The narrator expresses their love for their partner but also the pain and frustration they feel because of their actions. The story conveyed in the song revolves around a turbulent relationship. The narrator confronts their partner about their behavior and expresses their desire for understanding and reconciliation. However, despite the love they have for their partner, they realize that they can't continue living in such turmoil. The lyrics also touch upon feelings of betrayal and the narrator's realization that they deserve better treatment. They reference catching their partner "honky-tonkin'" with their best friend, indicating infidelity. Overall, the song captures the emotions of a person who is deeply hurt and questioning why their partner's actions continue to cause them pain. It speaks to the complexities of love and the struggle to make sense of a troubled relationship.
