Jim Cuddy's song "What Is So Wrong" explores the theme of change and the devastating effects it can have on relationships. The lyrics depict a sense of loss and confusion as the narrator reflects on a person they once knew. The song suggests that this person has transformed into someone heartless and unrecognizable. The line, "Whatever became of the one that we knew, When did heartless raven ever become you," conveys the narrator's disappointment and disbelief in how this person has changed. They question how this transformation occurred, and it is evident that this change was not anticipated. The lyrics also touch on the fleeting nature of life and the importance of cherishing what we have before it is gone. The line, "Cause you never even noticed the world gone by, Could be gone in the blink of an eye" emphasizes the fragility of time and the need to appreciate the present. The song suggests that both parties are responsible for the deterioration of their relationship. The verse, "You gotta admit that it's funny the mess that we made, Maybe we could have fixed it, but there was nothing to save," implies that they both played a role in the downfall and missed opportunities to salvage their connection. The narrator expresses their internal struggle and reluctance to confront the situation directly. They admit, "I could walk right down there, but I'm not that brave." This demonstrates their fear of facing the reality of the relationship's demise. The mention of a place they used to go together, where poets gathered and everyone is now gone, symbolizes the loss of familiarity and the impossibility of returning to what once was. It highlights the finality of change and the inability to go back to the way things were. Overall, Jim Cuddy's "What Is So Wrong" delves into the complexities of change, loss, and the impact it can have on relationships. It conveys a sense of longing and confusion, ultimately prompting listeners to reflect on their own experiences with change and its consequences.
