The song "Counterfeit Love" by Johnny Horton tells the story of a relationship filled with deception and betrayal. The lyrics describe a love that is fake and dishonest, symbolized by the term "counterfeit love." The narrator expresses their disappointment and pain in realizing that their partner has been pretending to love them through broken promises and countless lies. The person singing the song acknowledges that while they may desire to show love and affection towards their partner, their partner always remains emotionally distant, or "cold." However, it confuses them when others claim that the same partner is affectionate and warm towards them. This contrast between their personal experience and the perception of others underscores the deceitful nature of the partner's love. Ultimately, the lyrics emphasize the fake and insincere nature of the love that the narrator believed to be genuine. The repeated mention of "a broken vow and a million lies" highlights the accumulation of deception and unkept promises that have shattered their trust. Through "Counterfeit Love," Johnny Horton explores themes of betrayal, deception, and the emotional turmoil that comes from realizing that someone you love has been pretending and lying all along.