The song "What If (I Told You I Like You)" by Johnny Orlando and Mackenzie Ziegler is about the uncertainty and fear of expressing romantic feelings towards someone. The lyrics depict a conversation between two individuals who are contemplating whether or not to confess their feelings for each other. Johnny begins by suggesting that they discuss topics that are typically avoided in conversation, implying that they want to broach the subject of their potential romantic interest in each other. He questions if the other person ever thinks about their relationship and wonders if he should continue asking or if he should stop altogether. The chorus then presents the main theme of the song, with Johnny and Kenzie both expressing their desire to confess their feelings. They wonder about the outcome of such a declaration, asking what would happen if they admitted liking each other. They ponder whether they should take the risk of being together, knowing that it could also lead to heartbreak. Despite their doubts, they can't help but think about the possibility and what they might have been missing. Kenzie then shares her perspective, acknowledging the rumors and gossip surrounding their relationship but emphasizing that it's ultimately about their own feelings. She questions whether the situation would be simple or complicated and whether it would be better to continue pursuing the potential relationship or to stop and avoid any potential complications. The song concludes with Johnny and Kenzie together in the chorus, asking each other the hypothetical question of what would happen if they confessed their feelings for one another. They go back and forth, contemplating the possibilities before realizing that they both like each other. Overall, "What If (I Told You I Like You)" explores the uncertainties and hesitations that come with admitting feelings for someone and the internal struggle to decide whether to take the risk or not.
