The song "Evil Girl" by Jon Caryl tells the story of a person who is deeply in love with someone who turns out to be manipulative and deceitful. The lyrics express the speaker's realization and regret for not recognizing the true nature of this person sooner. The song begins with the speaker expressing their longing for this person and questioning where they went wrong in their relationship. The speaker acknowledges that the person they loved was actually evil all along and admits that they should have known. The lyrics go on to describe how this person played with the speaker's emotions, opening up to them only to break their heart and tear their life apart. The speaker laments that they should have realized sooner that this person would only bring them down and that their relationship was constantly unstable. The speaker also mentions that they stuck around even though the relationship was toxic, expressing gratitude for the person finally noticing them. They reflect on how they were only trying to love this person, but question why they didn't receive love in return. The lyrics further describe the realization of the person's true nature, referring to their eyes as filled with demons and how they only wanted to socialize and manipulate others. The speaker acknowledges that they fell for an idealized version of this person that existed in their mind, unable to see their imperfections. Overall, the song "Evil Girl" explores themes of love, deception, and regret. It tells the story of being blind-sided by someone's true nature and the aftermath of realizing that the person you loved was not who you thought they were.