Keith Urban's song "That Could Still Be Us" is about the lingering feelings and regrets after a relationship ends. The lyrics reflect on the memories and moments shared with a past love and the pain of realizing that those moments are now in the past. The song begins with the narrator unable to sleep, staring at their phone and wondering who will give in first and reach out to the other person. They express a desire to not be alone and to not feel the hurt of the breakup. The narrator reminisces about the nights spent together, especially in specific locations like driveways and backyards, where they felt like the only two people in the world. The lyrics show the narrator's struggle with the breakup, admitting that they may be crazy for still holding onto the hope that they could still be together. They acknowledge that sometimes, in their dreams or thoughts, it feels like they are still together. They express the pain of constantly thinking about their ex-partner but also acknowledge that they do so because they are still holding onto the possibility of a future reunion. The song continues with the narrator going to a riverbank and seeing their ex-partner's face in the water. They mention the whispers of the small-town summer wind reminding them of their mistakes. The lyrics convey the pain and emptiness the narrator feels and how nothing else can fill that void. The chorus repeats, emphasizing that the narrator still believes there is a chance for them to be together again. They confess that they think about their ex-partner too much, but it's because they still have feelings and hope for a possible reconciliation. The song ends with a bittersweet reflection on missed opportunities. The narrator mentions seeing their ex-partner's taillights fading in the dark, regretting not calling out their name. They also mention driving by the same spot and reliving everything in their mind. The lyrics contemplate what could have been, what should have been, and what actually happened. Overall, "That Could Still Be Us" conveys the pain, longing, and hope that often accompany the aftermath of a breakup. It explores the nostalgia for a past relationship and the ongoing desire for a second chance.
