"Church Girl" by Maddi Jane is a song that delves into the conflicting emotions and struggles of the protagonist, who identifies as a church girl. The lyrics explore themes of loneliness, questioning one's faith, and the damaging effects of perfectionism. In the beginning, the protagonist describes the beauty of stained glass windows in the church but acknowledges that they do not offer solace or understanding for her inner pain. She feels as though her suffering goes unnoticed or ignored by those around her. The protagonist kneels silently at the front of the church, suggesting she is going through the motions of her religious upbringing, even though she feels that the damage has already been done. She feels as though her story is wasted and wonders what is left for her to experience when everything is devoid of meaning or satisfaction. The concept of perfectionism is highlighted as the protagonist refers to it as a "bitch." She suggests that if one adheres to perfectionism, they may achieve external success but may also experience an internal struggle. The cries of her pain echo through the church, reaching the highest points of the steeples, indicating the depth of her emotional turmoil. The chorus poses a hypothetical question: would love meet her in the church? The protagonist wonders if love, in any form, would be brave enough to confront her in her vulnerable state or if it would shy away. She reflects on her past, where the church was once her home, but now she feels alone. The protagonist acknowledges that something inside her has changed, altering her perception and experience of her faith. She struggles to find the right words when it is time to pray, unsure of who is on the other end. She feels that her actions are seen and judged, which leaves her feeling silenced. The song ends with a repetition of the chorus, emphasizing the protagonist's longing for love and a sense of belonging. She expresses her desire to return to being a church girl, implying that something has caused her to deviate from her original connection with her faith. She laments being lost in her thoughts, crying with red eyes, and hitting dead ends in life. Overall, "Church Girl" explores the emotional journey of a person facing internal struggles within the context of their faith. It reflects on the isolating effects of perfectionism and the longing for understanding and love within a religious community.
