The song "What If?" by Mckenna Grace tells the story of a toxic relationship and the aftermath of a breakup. The lyrics explore the narrator's thoughts and emotions as they reflect on what could have been different and the negative experiences they had with their former partner. The song begins with the narrator questioning what would have happened if certain events didn't take place, such as parking their car in a particular parking lot or going to a shopping mall where they first encountered their ex. These thoughts prompt the narrator to wonder if things could have turned out differently and if they would still be together. As the song progresses, the narrator expresses their feelings towards their ex. They reveal that they often think of them and defend them to their friends, possibly indicating conflicting emotions or lingering attachments. However, they also admit to hating their ex, not wanting to see them again, and resenting the pain they caused. The second half of the song focuses on the mistreatment the narrator endured during their relationship. They mention being left alone at a party and feeling isolated, wishing their ex treated them with kindness and respect. The lyrics become more intense as the narrator describes their former partner as a sociopathic lying piece of shit. The chorus repeats the questions about the narrator's thoughts and actions after the breakup. They wonder if they still hold onto memories and reminders of their ex, indicating a struggle to let go. However, they ultimately affirm that they have deleted all their photos and love the feeling of pretending they never met. Overall, "What If?" explores the emotional journey of a toxic relationship, addressing themes of regret, resentment, and the process of moving on. It showcases the conflicting emotions and the aftermath of a painful breakup, highlighting the strength in letting go and finding closure.
