The song "Who Are You" by Scarlett Johansson explores themes of deception, self-identity, and the complexities of relationships. The lyrics depict a sense of disillusionment and betrayal. The song begins by describing a carnival-like atmosphere, where people are lining up to experience the thrill of a Tilt-a-Whirl ride. This imagery can be seen as a metaphor for the ups and downs of a tumultuous relationship. The mention of winning a real live doll symbolizes the objectification and manipulation that can occur within such partnerships. The protagonist of the song confesses that they believed the lies told by their partner, who is now urged to take them back to their metaphorical "red house" where they can address their fears and face the darkness within their relationship. The lyrics then shift to a prison metaphor, indicating that the protagonist has done their time imprisoned by the manipulations and deceptions of their partner. Ophelia, a reference to Shakespeare's tragic character, represents someone seeking guidance on which path to take amidst the confusion and pain. The protagonist questions their partner's actions, asking what they did in the past when faced with similar situations. The mention of time not being a friend implies that the passage of time has revealed more of the partner's true colors. The lyrics delve into religious and self-destructive imagery, questioning whether the partner cries, prays, or wishes away the consequences of their actions. The mention of leaving nothing but bones in the way suggests a trail of destruction left in their wake. The burial of the carnival with lions alludes to the end of the carefree and exciting aspects of the relationship. Scarlett Johansson then confronts the partner, asking who they are pretending to be this time and noting their fatigue. The references to a pistol, a Bible, and sleeping pills imply the partner's reliance on destructive coping mechanisms. The mention of jumping out of windows in expensive clothes suggests a desire to escape reality while maintaining appearances. The protagonist confesses that they fell in love with the partner's rough language and wounded eyes, but now the situation has escalated to a war-like environment. The lyrics conclude with the repeated question of who the partner is this time, reflecting the uncertainty and confusion the protagonist feels about their identity. Overall, "Who Are You" explores the disillusionment and complexity of a toxic relationship where deception, manipulation, and self-destruction play a significant role.
