The song "Brand New Heartache" by The Everly Brothers tells the story of a person who experiences heartache and disappointment in a new relationship. The lyrics describe how a new boy comes to town, and the singer realizes that they haven't seen him before. However, instead of bringing happiness and excitement, this new person brings a sense of impending heartache. The singer reflects on a similar experience in the past when someone moved in next door and caused a heartache. They question why they can't trust this person and why they constantly try to make them feel sad and blue. In the song, the singer describes how they had made plans for a ball or event, but the person never showed up. This further deepens the heartache they are feeling, as they were disappointed and left waiting. Moreover, the person is consistently late for their dates, adding to the frustration and expectation of another heartache to come. The song portrays the emotions and vulnerability that come with new relationships, highlighting the fear of being hurt again and the struggle to trust in someone new. The lyrics suggest that the protagonist is aware of the pattern of heartache and yet still finds themselves caught up in it.
