The Flying Machine's song "That Same Old Feeling" is about the lingering pain and longing that comes with not being able to get over a past relationship. The lyrics describe how the protagonist is still haunted by memories of their ex-partner, unable to move on despite trying to convince themselves that they have. The song paints a picture of nostalgia and heartache, with references to a carved oak tree and an overgrown cottage that serve as reminders of the love that once was. The chorus repeats the phrase "I'm still not over you," emphasizing the lingering emotions that continue to plague the protagonist. Overall, "That Same Old Feeling" captures the universal experience of heartbreak and the difficulty of moving on from a past relationship. It conveys a sense of sadness and longing, resonating with listeners who have experienced similar feelings of unrequited love.