The lyrics of "Like I Can" by Tough Love & Karen Harding depict a story of unrequited love and the longing for someone who is in a relationship with someone else. The protagonist of the song is deeply attracted to a person who is already committed to another person. The lyrics express the protagonist's frustration and confusion as they struggle to move on from the previous night's encounter with this person, finding it hard to forget about them. The protagonist can see that the person they desire is not being loved the same way that they could love them, but there is no certainty that things will work out between them. The chorus emphasizes the protagonist's desire to be with this person, noting that they want to be seen as their "baby" or partner. They believe they deserve more than just casual encounters and are looking for a deeper connection. The lyrics also highlight the protagonist's need for action and honesty in the relationship. They express that they are willing to put their heart out for this person, but they expect reciprocity and respect in return. Ultimately, the song conveys the protagonist's struggle and hope to be the preferred choice over the person's current partner. It depicts their desire to be seen as the one who can truly love and understand them, offering a sense of escape and fulfillment for both individuals involved.