Cody Johnson's song "Underneath This Hat" tells the story of a cowboy who walks into a bar and later into a church, wrestling with his inner demons and identity. The lyrics describe how the protagonist wears his hat low, symbolizing his hidden struggles and complexities. In the first verse, the protagonist enters a bar, feeling like a stranger in town. He enjoys the atmosphere and decides to play pool. However, a woman approaches him and questions why he keeps his hat pulled down low. He responds by explaining that underneath his hat, there is both a devil and an angel, representing his inner conflict between good and bad. The second verse takes place in a church, where the protagonist attends a service to reflect on his actions. The preacher talks about damnation and the need for change. The preacher calls him out and suggests he removes his hat, metaphorically encouraging him to confront his inner conflicts. Once again, the protagonist explains that beneath his hat, there is a mix of pride, guilt, and the desire for redemption. Throughout the song, the lyrics emphasize the duality of the protagonist's nature. He has both a Texan spirit, representing his pride and strong identity, and a sinner trying to find salvation. His hat serves as a metaphorical disguise, hiding his internal struggles and complexities. Overall, "Underneath This Hat" explores themes of self-reflection, inner conflict, and the search for redemption. It delves into the protagonist's struggle to reconcile his conflicting characteristics and find his place in the world.
