The song "You Thought I'd Never Be" by Cody Johnson tells the story of a relationship that has ended, highlighting the emotional journey of the narrator after their breakup. The lyrics express the narrator's realization of how wrong they were for getting over their ex-partner and playing the fool in the relationship. At the same time, the song also acknowledges the ex-partner's wrongdoings in playing with the narrator's heart. The chorus reflects the narrator's acceptance of their loneliness and the starting point of their healing process. They ask the ex-partner not to pay attention to the empty sheets that symbolize their past shared moments, as the bed they now lie in is of their own making. The mention of hindsight being twenty-twenty suggests that both parties may eventually recognize their respective faults. The second verse reveals the narrator's longing for their ex-partner to change their mind, but they acknowledge that it may be too late for reconciliation. Despite this, the narrator expresses gratitude for being able to find happiness and a new light in someone else's eyes. The bridge reflects the narrator's hope for their ex-partner's sadness and regret, wishing them long, cold nights and reliving a love that is already dead. The lyrics suggest that the ex-partner's search for fulfillment and their selfish pride will only lead to their own downfall. In the final chorus, the narrator reaffirms their stance that they have always been the person their ex-partner underestimated and never believed in. They express satisfaction that their ex-partner will be the one losing sleep over the situation, while the narrator moves forward with their life. Overall, "You Thought I'd Never Be" conveys the emotional journey of moving on from a failed relationship, acknowledging both parties' mistakes and finding strength in personal growth and self-belief.
