"Murder After Midnight" by Geto Boys tells the story of a series of violent events that take place late at night. The song is narrated by different members of the rap group, each taking on their own perspective and recounting their experiences. The song begins with Big Mike riding through the park when he is suddenly ambushed by gunmen. Shocked and angry, he retrieves his own weapon and prepares to retaliate. He calls his friend, Face, for assistance but discovers that Face's associate, Matt, has been killed by the same assailants. Determined to seek revenge, they arrange to meet up and formulate a plan. Scarface takes over the next verse, expressing his frustration and vengeful intentions. He vows to punish the individuals responsible for their friend's death. He arms himself with a Smith & Wesson revolver and they set out to find the culprits. Aware of the dangers they face, they proceed cautiously, using a stolen car to remain inconspicuous. They come across a target, referred to as the "Z" and open fire. However, their attempt is met with opposition as the person they shot at returns fire. The rappers manage to escape unscathed, turning the situation into a gunfight. Scarface emphasizes his willingness to resort to violence and proves his commitment to exacting revenge. Finally, Bushwick Bill takes the last verse, joining the pursuit in a van with a group of armed individuals. They encounter the fleeing suspect and shoot at him, not hesitating to take multiple lives. Bill boasts about their weaponry and intimidation tactics, suggesting they do not want any witnesses to their actions. The only known account of the incident is that it occurred after midnight, signifying the darkness and secrecy surrounding their violent deeds. Overall, "Murder After Midnight" portrays a gritty and violent narrative, highlighting the ruthless actions undertaken by the Geto Boys in their pursuit of vengeance.