The song "Why, Oh Why, Oh Why" by Gilbert O'Sullivan is a heartfelt and emotional plea to understand the reasons behind the cruelty and indifference shown by his partner. The lyrics reflect his confusion and desperation as he tries to comprehend why his loved one treats him so unkindly. Throughout the song, Gilbert questions why his partner acts cold and distant towards him. He wonders why she insists on being cruel in order to show kindness and why she rejects his affectionate gestures like holding her close or kissing her. He expresses his frustration and desire to know what he has done wrong to deserve such treatment. The song also highlights the strain in their relationship. Gilbert observes that whenever they visit his friends, she never wants to go, indicating a lack of interest in his life. When he feels happy, she expects him to be low, adding to his confusion and sadness. He questions her sudden change in behavior after years of being together, as she acts as if they've hardly spoken or met. Gilbert's emotional state is evident as he expresses his distress and asks why she doesn't love him anymore. He wonders if she has simply had enough of him and why he is always left crying himself to sleep. The repetition of "Oh why, oh why, oh why" emphasizes his desperation to understand and find resolution. The lyrics suggest that Gilbert is willing to make a change if his partner can communicate her feelings honestly and openly. He pleads for an explanation, as he cannot bear the heartbreak of not knowing why she has become so angry and distant.
