The song "Why" by Gotthard explores feelings of betrayal, loss, and the struggle to understand why someone would hurt others. The lyrics suggest that there is a person who tries to avoid seeing the truth and ignores the pain they cause. They continue to deceive themselves until they can no longer deny the reality. The singer acknowledges that this person was hurting and pretending to be fine. However, eventually, their actions catch up with them and they become burned out, possibly referring to their deceitful behavior. The chorus asks why this person feels the need to take advantage of others and steal their happiness, symbolized by the moon. It questions why their presence is necessary for others to feel joy, suggesting that they derive satisfaction from manipulating and hurting others. The verses highlight the personal connection the singer had with this person, mentioning that they spoke with them just a week before they were gone. The regret and longing to have known about the impending betrayal hangs heavily in the air. The person's words never truly expressed their true feelings, leading to a sense of silent anguish and a desperate attempt to convey their pain through a letter. The song ultimately expresses a mix of confusion, hurt, and anger towards this person who continuously takes from others, leaving devastation in their wake. It conveys the desire to understand their motivations and shed light on the pain they inflict on others.
