Jenny Hval's song Thumbsucker is a surreal and introspective exploration of the self, identity, and the relationship between humans and nature. The lyrics describe a journey through wildscapes, alternating between the forest and human worlds, as the protagonist grapples with their past and present selves. The opening lines invite the listener to join the protagonist in falling into the wildscape and reversing the church bells, which could be interpreted as a symbol of rebellion against societal norms and expectations. The image of swiping in the mud with two fingers and one in the mouth suggests a childlike playfulness and exploration. The chorus of the song, "I was a thumbsucker, what am I now?", reflects the protagonist's confusion and uncertainty about their identity. It's unclear whether they are a traveler, a runaway, or simply someone who colors outside the lines and avoids confrontation. The lyrics allude to self-harm and vampirism, but also suggest tenderness and a desire for compensation. The line "producing nothing. Until are equals" could be interpreted as a call for acceptance and harmony between humans and nature, rather than a hierarchy or domination. The lyrics also discuss the fear of digging too deep into the self and releasing instinctual desires and fears, and the constant process of constructing oneself. Overall, Thumbsucker is a poetic and thought-provoking exploration of self-discovery and the relationship between humanity and the natural world.
