Jenny Hval's song "Why This?" is a contemplative and introspective piece that questions the significance of our choices and desires. Through the lyrics, Hval reflects on the complexity of human emotions and the need for love and connection. The opening lines, "How thick is a surface? Why this and not that?" suggest that Hval is attempting to understand the nature of superficiality and the reasons behind the choices we make in our lives. She then introduces the idea of "the deepest human longing," which she believes is to be loved. Hval acknowledges that she is a complex and intellectual person, but she still acknowledges the importance of love and connection. This theme is repeated throughout the song, as she asks, "Why this and not that?" and declares her desire to make everyone cry together. The meaning behind the haunting sound in her throat is open to interpretation, but it could be seen as a manifestation of the emotional pain that Hval is trying to convey through her music. Overall, "Why This?" is a thought-provoking and emotional exploration of the human experience and the power of our deepest longings.
