John Cale's song "Hallelujah" is a cover of Leonard Cohen's original composition. The lyrics depict a complex and emotionally charged narrative. The song begins by referencing a secret chord that David played, which pleased the Lord. This draws from the biblical story of David, who was known for playing his harp and singing songs of praise to God. However, the narrator acknowledges that the listener may not have the same appreciation for music. The following lines describe the chord progression of the song, highlighting the fourth, the fifth, the minor fall, and the major lift. These musical terms represent the different emotional tones in the song. The "baffled king composing Hallelujah" refers to David's struggle to find the right words to express his devotion to God through his music. Moving forward, the lyrics portray a narrative of lost love. The narrator mentions a person with strong faith who seeks proof and is captivated by the beauty of another person. However, their relationship turns destructive, symbolized by being tied to a kitchen chair and having their throne and hair broken. Despite this, they still find solace in singing "Hallelujah." The song then shifts to a new perspective, with the narrator reflecting on their own experience. They reveal that they have been in a similar situation before and have seen the other person's flag on the Marble Arch, implying their shared history. The mention of love not being a victory march suggests that love can be challenging and painful, leading to a cold and broken "Hallelujah." Continuing, the lyrics express a longing for a deeper connection. The narrator recalls a time when the person they love used to share their true feelings, but now keeps it hidden. They reminisce about a past intimate encounter, where their actions were accompanied by the presence of a holy dove, a symbol of purity and divine inspiration. Each breath they took together was a manifestation of "Hallelujah." The song's final verses convey a sense of disillusionment. The narrator ponders the existence of a higher power and reflects on the lessons they've learned from love. They describe love as a battlefield, where they have been hurt by someone who got the upper hand. The cry at night is not a sign of spiritual enlightenment but rather a testament to the pain of a cold and broken "Hallelujah." Overall, John Cale's rendition of "Hallelujah" explores themes of love, spirituality, longing, and vulnerability. The lyrics intricately weave together different narratives to convey a poignant and reflective message.
