"What If I Came Knocking" is a song by John Mellencamp that explores the uncertainty and vulnerability of love and relationships. The lyrics depict the narrator imagining various scenarios in which they approach someone they care about, seeking different responses. In the song, the narrator wonders what would happen if they showed up unannounced at someone's doorstep, bedpost, or even in their thoughts. They question whether the person would welcome them with open arms or put up walls to protect themselves. The narrator contemplates whether their boldness might scare the other person away or if their fears of committing to something real are holding them back. The repeated refrain, "So what if I came knocking?" emphasizes the narrator's desire for a genuine connection. They are willing to take a risk and expose their true feelings, whether it leads to a happy ending or not. The song highlights the unpredictability of love and the fear of potential heartbreak. The narrator acknowledges that relationships can be like a game of chance, where the outcome is uncertain and often difficult to foresee. They express the possibility of things not working out as planned and the potential for being hurt or rejected. Overall, "What If I Came Knocking" delves into the complexities of love, vulnerability, and the fear of rejection. It captures the emotional rollercoaster that comes with opening oneself up to someone and the uncertainty that can accompany taking that leap of faith.
