The song "I Don't Believe You" by John Nolan expresses his skepticism and doubt towards something or someone he loves. He describes himself as a born disciple, someone who is devoted and loyal, but also inherently suspicious. Despite his coherent nature, he longs for the blissful lack of rationality and wants to find ways to embrace inconsistency and confusion. Nolan struggles to find clever words to express his disbelief but fails. He straightforwardly states that he does not believe the subject, emphasizing his lack of faith or trust. He feels the need to clarify that he is not trying to demean or have all the answers. Instead, he desires a sense of balance in his life and decides to tune out the subject, suggesting they do the same in return. The song reflects Nolan's personal journey of questioning and asserting his own beliefs. It explores themes of self-discovery, skepticism, and the desire for emotional equilibrium.
