The meaning and story of Joseph Arthur's song "Birthday Card" revolves around a tumultuous and complicated relationship between two individuals. In the lyrics, the protagonist narrates a series of emotions and experiences related to their connection. The song begins with the narrator's partner writing their name with a heart inside a birthday card. The PS (postscript) suggests that the recipient might misinterpret their intentions and implies that their feelings are not easily discernible. This confusion creates a mess in the narrator's mind. The protagonist expresses their conflicting emotions, stating that the love they feel for their partner also brings out their own insecurities and flaws, making them feel ugly. This realization prompts the decision to take back the love they had given to their partner. The narrator then talks about their need to distance themselves from the situation and find solace in a hiding place. Looking into their partner's eyes makes them uncomfortable because it feels as though their partner can see through their facade. This suggests a lack of genuine connection or understanding between the two. The song also features a back-and-forth perspective. The second verse is from the partner's point of view, writing their name with the narrator's heart on a postcard. They express their loneliness and admit that the narrator made them the happiest. However, since the narrator left, they have been left feeling like a mess. The partner reminisces about the physical intimacy they shared, comparing it to digging deep into the ground, discovering something precious. They were made to feel powerful and important, likened to a king in their partner's realm. The partner acknowledges being manipulated and enticed by their partner's guilty pleasure. Overall, "Birthday Card" depicts a complex and tumultuous relationship where both individuals struggle with their emotions and the consequences of their actions. The song touches upon themes of love, insecurity, manipulation, and the fragility of human connections.
