The song "I Should Care" was written by Sammy Cahn, Axel Stordahl, and Paul Weston and was popularized by Julie London. It is a ballad that explores themes of love, heartbreak, and emotional vulnerability. In the lyrics, the speaker expresses that they should care about a past relationship ending and the pain it has caused them. They acknowledge that they should be feeling upset, sleepless, and tearful over the breakup. However, despite these expectations, the speaker admits that they are surprisingly able to sleep well, except for a few dreams. They find solace in counting sheep, which has a calming effect. The contradiction between what the speaker should feel and what they actually feel is highlighted in the lyrics. The speaker acknowledges that they may not find someone as lovely as their past partner, but still, they struggle to feel the expected level of sadness and distress. Overall, the song conveys a complex mix of emotions. It suggests that even though the speaker recognizes they should care about the loss of the relationship, they struggle to fully feel the expected pain. It explores the idea that sometimes emotions and reactions do not align with societal expectations or the "shoulds" imposed upon us.
