"Tell-Tale Heart" is a song by Sara Groves that delves into themes of memory, hidden truths, and the weight of past experiences. The lyrics suggest that the past, represented as a blurry memory, can still hold significance and influence in the present. The line "All is well the past is in the past" highlights the idea that despite moving forward, the past can still have an impact on us. The song also portrays a sense of duality, with smiling and welcoming guests on the surface while hiding dark secrets. The lyrics mention bodies in the basement, laughing at a joke too soon, and gliding through the living room. These images suggest a facade of happiness and normalcy, while underneath lie hidden truths or buried emotions. The phrase "tell-tale heart" references Edgar Allan Poe's short story of the same name. In the story, the narrator is consumed by guilt and paranoia, with the sound of a beating heart symbolizing their guilt. This connection implies that the song explores the feelings of guilt or remorse that can arise when confronted with hidden truths or unresolved issues. Overall, "Tell-Tale Heart" captures the complexity of human experiences, where past memories can influence our present actions, and the weight of hidden truths can be felt despite attempts to maintain a facade. The song encourages personal reflection and the importance of acknowledging and addressing the truth in order to find healing and forgiveness.