The Everly Brothers' song "Lucille" tells the story of a person pleading for their lover, Lucille, to come back to them. The lyrics suggest that Lucille is not following or fulfilling the expectations or desires of her father, but despite that, the singer still loves her. They ask Lucille to return to them because they have treated her well and don't want to be left alone. The song portrays a sense of longing and desperation as the singer wakes up one morning to find Lucille missing. When they inquire about her whereabouts, their friends remain tight-lipped, possibly indicating that they know something the singer doesn't. Overall, "Lucille" conveys the protagonist's strong emotions about their relationship with Lucille and their desire for her to come back and be with them. It is a heartfelt plea for the return of their beloved partner, even though she may not meet societal expectations or live up to her father's will.