The Everly Brothers' song "Should We Tell Him" tells a story about a man who becomes suspicious of his girlfriend's loyalty. The lyrics are about the narrator's internal struggle as he debates whether or not to inform his friend about his girlfriend's unfaithfulness. The song begins with an ambiguous humming sound, setting a contemplative tone. The narrator questions whether they should reveal the truth to the friend, acknowledging that it wouldn't be fair for him to continue trusting his girlfriend if she doesn't care about him. The story unfolds as the narrator takes his girlfriend to his best friend's mansion for a dance. However, during the event, the friend secretly calls the girlfriend over and whispers something to her. The narrator overhears this interaction, indicating that there may be something suspicious going on. Feeling hurt and betrayed, the narrator decides to leave them together. In an attempt to distract himself, he goes to a café where his friends are gathered for fun and laughter. However, he overhears two of his friends discussing the situation, wondering if they should inform him about his girlfriend's lack of loyalty. The song concludes with the recurring question of whether they should tell him or not, emphasizing the internal conflict faced by the narrator and his friends. The lyrics capture the emotional turmoil and the moral dilemma of choosing whether to disclose the truth and potentially disrupt their friend's trust and happiness. Overall, "Should We Tell Him" explores themes of loyalty, truth, and the weight of secrets within friendships and relationships.
