The song "Sugarcoated" by Gatlin explores the complexities and contradictions of a toxic relationship. The lyrics express the narrator's desire for honesty and clarity from their partner, even if it means hearing painful truths. The mention of "the taste you left sticks to my teeth" suggests that the memories of their relationship linger and are hard to forget. The chorus revolves around the concept of sugarcoating, which refers to the act of making something appear sweeter or better than it actually is. The narrator acknowledges that their relationship is not healthy or fulfilling, yet they continue to deceive themselves, possibly due to the addictive nature of their connection. The references to "coke in my whiskey" and "get high enough to crash again" allude to self-destructive behaviors and the cycle of making the same mistakes. Despite knowing the relationship is broken and loaded with uncertainties, the narrator chooses to pretend they are unaware of its flaws. They question whether it would be easier if their partner would just leave them, indicating a desire for freedom from the toxic situation. However, their emotions are conflicted, as they also express longing and difficulty in letting go. Overall, "Sugarcoated" explores the themes of addiction, deception, and the complexities of love. It highlights the struggle between holding onto a toxic relationship and the desire for honesty and closure.