"Fall Into Me" by Hey Monday is a love song about two people who are hesitant to fully give in to their feelings for each other. The lyrics describe the intense connection they feel whenever they're near each other, but also the fear of misreading each other's signals and the uncertainty of where their relationship is headed. Despite their reservations, the singer longs for the other person and is willing to take the risk of falling in love. They acknowledge that things aren't simple anymore, but they're still willing to close their eyes and hold on tight to every moment they have together. Overall, "Fall Into Me" is a plea for the other person to let their guard down and allow themselves to fall for each other, putting aside their fears and uncertainties and embracing their deepening connection.