James Hersey's song "We Might Fall" tells the story of two individuals who are hesitant to fall in love again due to past experiences. The protagonist sings about how they can't stop thinking about the nights they've had with their romantic interest and how they remember almost every word that was said. They express admiration for the way their love interest talks about their past and how they use their hands to communicate. The protagonist finds their love interest's body to be a reflection of their soul, making them unforgettable. Although both individuals have reservations about falling in love, they acknowledge that there is still a possibility for them to experience the strong emotions associated with it. The protagonist admits to previously declaring that they might never fall in love again, while their love interest stated they don't need a partner. However, despite their doubts, they both recognize that they have a lot of love to give. As the song progresses, the protagonist becomes more certain about their feelings, believing that it won't be long before they realize their love interest is the only person they need. They describe a moment of waking up and finding their love interest in bed with them, a memory they'll never forget. The protagonist appreciates the way their love interest talks about their friends and the way they physically engage with them. They once again emphasize the connection between their love interest's body and their soul. Although the protagonist still acknowledges their previous reluctance towards love and their love interest's skepticism, they both acknowledge that they have a chance of falling in love once again. They believe they still have so much love to give and that they might fall in love with each other. Throughout the song, there is a sense of vulnerability and a willingness to overcome past hurt in order to embrace love once more. It highlights the powerful emotions and uncertainty that can arise when two people are considering the possibility of falling in love again.