John Grant：Meaning of Touch And Go Songmeaning

"Touch and Go" by John Grant is a song about Chelsea Manning, a former U.S. Army intelligence analyst who leaked classified military and diplomatic documents to WikiLeaks in 2010. The lyrics question the narrative and perception surrounding Manning's actions and highlight the profound change she has experienced. The song begins by addressing the misinformation and opinions that have been spread about Manning and the way things are. It reflects on how unforeseen it may have been for Manning to have come so far, considering the obstacles she faced. There was a period of uncertainty, symbolized by the phrase "touch and go," where her fate hung in the balance. The lyrics then delve into Manning's childhood, wondering if she played with Barbie dolls when no one else was around. This question emphasizes the contrast between her past and the revolutionary actions she later took. The ignorance mentioned could refer to the lack of understanding or awareness society had of Manning's struggles and eventual transformation. The song continues by contemplating Manning's state of mind as she faced the consequences of her actions. It acknowledges the physical and emotional pain she endured as she was "struck down to the ground." The use of this imagery conveys the severe repercussions Manning faced for her leaked documents. Grant then criticizes those who claim to be patriotic but exhibit qualities of being robotic in blindly following the status quo. He suggests that they wouldn't be able to handle what Manning went through and are oblivious to the personal growth and strength she gained. The darkness that almost swallowed her up refers to the overwhelming challenges she faced. Despite the expectation to be incensed by Manning's actions, the lyrics express compassion and portray those who condemn her as liars. Grant recognizes the secrecy that Manning had to keep throughout her life but acknowledges that she has now reached a point of no return, where her truth is exposed. The song concludes by describing Manning as a butterfly, using the metaphor to symbolize her transformation and rebirth. She is described as being free on the inside, implying that despite the consequences, her actions have allowed her to embrace her true self. The lyrics also emphasize that nothing can halt the progress of the truth, no matter how hard others try. In summary, "Touch and Go" highlights the challenges and transformation of Chelsea Manning, focusing on the misconceptions surrounding her actions and the personal growth she has undergone. It portrays her as a figure who has overcome immense obstacles to live her truth and challenges the societal judgment directed towards her.