"Never Meant To Break Your Heart" by Underoath is a song that explores themes of heartbreak, self-discovery, and the complex nature of love. The lyrics depict a protagonist who is experiencing emotional turmoil and the genuine remorse they feel for hurting someone they loved. The song begins with the protagonist expressing their sorrow as tears run down their face, comparing their current state to previous moments of pain. They feel sick when they see themselves in the mirror, questioning the authenticity of their prayers and feeling unable to wash away the guilt they carry. The lyrics then transition to the protagonist reflecting on a past relationship. They admit to being deceived by their partner's lies but grew to love them nonetheless. However, as time went on, the partner's true self was revealed, and the protagonist realized that their love was based on lust, not genuine affection. The chorus delves into the protagonist's feelings of hopelessness and questioning their place in the world. They wonder if the scars from their past will ever fade and if they will ever find their purpose or belonging. The song takes a religious turn as the protagonist reaches out to Jesus, seeking forgiveness and hoping for solace. They metaphorically rip their heart out to offer it to Jesus, admitting that being alone hasn't been beneficial for them. They ask for Jesus to hold them close and cleanse their mind, effectively seeking redemption and a transformation from the person they have become. Overall, "Never Meant To Break Your Heart" is a reflective and introspective song that explores the pain of hurting someone they loved, the struggle to find forgiveness, and the desire for personal growth and change.