The song "Tongue in Cheek" by Underscores tells a story about the admiration and idolization of a celebrity figure. The lyrics describe the singer's fascination with this person, reflecting on how they used to imitate their expressions and mannerisms at home. Despite being unknown by others, the singer would feel embarrassed if people did know the depth of their admiration. The lyrics also express a sense of loneliness and a desire for fame or recognition similar to the celebrity figure. The singer acknowledges their own insecurities and the high standards they feel have been set by this idol. The phrase "someone set some pretty fucking high standards" suggests a frustration with the unrealistic expectations placed upon them, possibly influenced by the perceived success and perfection of the celebrity. Overall, the song captures the emotions of longing, insecurity, and the impact of celebrity culture on personal identity.