The song "Put Your Big Toe in the Milk of Human Kindness" by Elvis Costello explores the unpredictable nature of humanity and our ability to be both compassionate and skeptical. The lyrics suggest that despite our origins from simple beings like frogs and fishes, our taste, or judgment, is not refined. The line "Put your big toe in the milk of human kindness" is a metaphorical invitation to experience and embrace kindness and compassion. The milk symbolizes the purity and goodness that can be found within humanity. By immersing oneself in it, one can connect with the inherent kindness that exists in people. The song also highlights our tendency to judge others based on superficial qualities. The lyrics mention how we elevate those who are considered attractive or cute, shooting them to starry heights. Yet, there's a sense of fickleness and suspicion when it comes to encountering wonders or extraordinary experiences. The contrast between the Himalayas and Manhattan's finest mountain top illustrates the idea that even great achievements or possessions can't always bring fulfillment. The whimsical nature of humanity is further emphasized by the reference to Father Christmas and the Virgin Mary, two iconic figures that elicit contrasting reactions. Overall, the song encourages listeners to let go of their skepticism and embrace the potential for kindness and compassion within themselves and others. It urges people to open their minds and experience moments of belief before they pass by.
