"When Did I Stop Dreaming?" is a song by Elvis Costello, released in 2002 as part of his album "When I Was Cruel." The song explores themes of lost innocence, confusion, and the longing for clarity in a relationship. The lyrics suggest that the protagonist was once lost in dreams or fantasies, and when reality sets in, they struggle to differentiate between what is real and what they may have imagined. The line "If this is not a dream, it's my mistake" signifies the uncertainty and doubt in their perception of reality. The protagonist expresses their detachment and eccentric behavior, asking for clarification on when they stopped dreaming. They question their own sanity and whether they may have hallucinated certain experiences. The lyrics also touch upon the fear of being judged by others ("people will talk") for their odd behavior. The song reveals regret and a desire to return to a state of innocence and blissful ignorance. The line "This is my nightmare, was this one dream too deep?" suggests the struggle to navigate through the complexity of the situation, viewing it as a waking nightmare. The protagonist implores someone for answers, seeking understanding and hoping for an end to their confusion. They feel trapped in limbo, neither good nor bad, and express a wish to spare others from their own turmoil. Overall, "When Did I Stop Dreaming?" tells a story of a person grappling with the loss of their dreams, the confusion of reality, and the longing for clarity and solace. The lyrics evoke a sense of introspection and vulnerability, showcasing the emotions and struggles of the protagonist.
