"When I Was Cruel No. 2" is a song by Elvis Costello from his album "When I Was Cruel" released in 2002. The song is a reflection on the artist's past and the changes that have occurred in his personal and professional life. The lyrics describe the protagonist stepping into the spotlight and being judged by others. They mockingly refer to the protagonist's previous relationships and imply that the current one is not genuine. The song alludes to the idea that the protagonist's success and image have made relationships more difficult and less authentic. The chorus, "But it was so much easier when I was cruel," suggests that the protagonist finds it harder to navigate relationships now that they have changed and become more complicated. The song comments on the protagonist's past behavior and the consequences it had on his relationships. The second part of the song discusses a social event where the protagonist interacts with various people, including younger wives, editors, and individuals from the protagonist's past. The lyrics touch on the theme of time passing and the changes that come with it. The mention of a tattoo received in '82 and being a "shaven-headed seaside thug" highlights the protagonist's rebellious past. Overall, "When I Was Cruel No. 2" explores the complexities and challenges of relationships and the impact of personal growth and success on one's ability to connect with others. The song reflects on the protagonist's past actions and the changes that have occurred over time, ultimately expressing a sense of nostalgia for a simpler, albeit crueler, time.
