The song "Paper Girl" by July Talk is a metaphorical representation of a person who is fragile, vulnerable, and easily manipulated by others. The lyrics depict someone who is insecure, cautious, and hesitant to trust others. The song starts by conveying a sense of distrust and discomfort. The narrator advises the "Paper Girl" not to ask questions or seek their trust because they don't appear attractive when they smile. This suggests that the person's vulnerability and lack of confidence make them appear unappealing. The following line, "You loved me like a doctor, horse don't run with a broken leg," implies that the person's love or care is limited and conditional. It suggests that they cannot provide proper support if the situation becomes difficult or challenging. The reference to a "Paper Girl" with "Paper Eyes" and "Paper Crop" reinforces the idea that the person is fragile and easily torn apart or manipulated. The lyrics also convey a sense of dominance and control. The narrator states that it is not the Paper Girl's turn to ask questions, indicating that they are controlling the conversation and the dynamics of the relationship. The refrain emphasizes the Paper Girl's desire for material possessions and the need to keep her emotions guarded. The suggestion of wanting money in coffee and secrets in tea implies that she seeks financial security and wants to protect her deepest emotions and vulnerabilities. The lyrics shift in the middle of the song, acknowledging the challenges and struggles faced by the Pretty Girl. It suggests that it must be hard for her to maintain her appearance and beauty while watching her body age. The chorus repeats the phrase "keep your Paper heart away from me," reinforcing the narrator's desire to distance themselves from the fragile and easily manipulated nature of the Paper Girl. Towards the end of the song, the tables seem to have turned. The Paper Girl is still present, but now she is singing in her electric chair. This line can be interpreted as a metaphor for the Paper Girl being trapped in her own vulnerability and insecurity. The song concludes with the repetition of the chorus, reiterating the narrator's insistence on keeping distances from someone who is fragile and easily manipulated. Overall, "Paper Girl" explores themes of vulnerability, manipulation, dominance, and the struggle to maintain appearances. It serves as a metaphor for individuals who find it difficult to trust others or assert themselves in relationships due to their fear of being hurt or controlled.
