"Pretender" by July Talk is a song about a charismatic and enigmatic individual who captivates those around them. The lyrics depict this person as someone who exudes confidence and control, able to influence and manipulate others with ease. The song begins by describing the person's entrance, comparing them to a luxury brand, Birkin, and their ability to convince and persuade others. They are portrayed as a preacher in a playhouse, someone who commands attention and respect. The lyrics hint that this person might have a questionable past, but they are not pretending to be someone they're not. The chorus emphasizes the person's mysterious nature and the way they defy conventional rules and expectations. They have a powerful presence that is beyond the comprehension of others. They don't conform to societal norms and don't let material wealth dictate their actions. The verses continue to depict their aura and influence. They are described as possessing a roomful of power that others cannot fully grasp. The lyrics also suggest that this person is not confined by boundaries and restrictions, metaphorically drifting through windows and defying legal regulations. The second part of the song focuses on the narrator's relationship with this person. They witness the person's captivating presence and are drawn to them. However, they also feel a sense of unease and question whether the person is genuine or simply performing for others. The narrator longs to understand this individual but feels overwhelmed by their complexity. As the song progresses, the narrator begins to understand the cost and consequences of the person's charismatic persona. They realize that they have lost touch with their true self and have been deceived by the superficial facade. The narrator feels ashamed for attempting to define and simplify the person, realizing that true understanding goes beyond surface-level perceptions. In the final lines, the song reveals the aftermath of the person's departure. The narrator sees the aftermath of their influence, scattered debris left behind. Despite the turmoil, the person remains unchanged and unafraid. The song ends by acknowledging that everyone is afraid of what they do not know, highlighting the universal struggle of understanding and finding genuine connections.
