The song "Rare Hearts" by The Growlers tells the story of a deep and intense love between two individuals. The lyrics paint a picture of a beautiful setting, possibly under an old oak tree or over a wild canyon, where the singer is captivated by the mesmerizing eyes of his loved one. The reference to the eyes being obsidian, which is a dark, volcanic stone, suggests a mysterious and alluring quality. The singer expresses his admiration for the person he loves, stating that he hasn't seen anything as beautiful as her. He believes that their love has the power to overcome any disagreements or conflicts, and they can remain inseparable like rare hearts. The lyrics also touch upon the idea of this love possibly being a dream. The singer mentions his tired eyes, indicating a state of weariness or uncertainty. He asks for guidance from a higher power, wishing to float downstream and surrender to the flow of life. The chorus repeats the question of whether it is too much to dream that their love can last forever without any disagreements. It seems like the singer is yearning for a love that is rare and unique, never fading or falling apart. Ultimately, the song conveys a sense of profound love and a desire for a lasting connection. The obsidian eyes symbolize the captivating and powerful effect the loved one has on the singer, and the rare hearts metaphor represents the rarity of finding a love that is truly harmonious and enduring.